Contractors bring their accounting back in-house for good reasons. They hired a controller, the volume outgrew the arrangement, or the work changed in a way the provider can't support. Fewer do it because of one rough month, and those are the ones who tend to regret it, because a missed close or a disagreement about scope is a conversation with your provider and not a sourcing decision.
If the reason is a real one, the next questions are what you have to get back, how long it takes, and what it costs. The answers depend mostly on how the work was set up in the first place.
Hire the person before you give notice. They should design the department, not inherit one. For a contractor that is a narrower search than it sounds. A controller who has built WIP schedules and tied them to the financials is hard to find, and a generalist will spend the first year learning percent complete and over and under billing on your jobs. Our post on what a construction controller is and why your company needs one covers what to look for.
When people talk about taking accounting back, they usually mean a long list of things to reclaim from the provider: the close checklist, the reconciliation support, the recurring entries, the admin rights, the accounting file itself. Every item on that list is something you can ask for today, while the relationship is good, instead of in the weeks after you give notice.
A simpler test is whether you could open the books on Monday and run them without anyone's permission. Does the work happen in your accounting system, on your chart of accounts? Do you hold the admin seat? Can you open this month's reconciliations and the close checklist right now? If the answer to all three is yes, there is nothing to reclaim, and taking the work back is a staffing decision instead of a project.
That is how we work. Your accounting stays in the system you already use. Our service is month to month with no contract, so there is no notice period to negotiate either.
Contractors don't lose deferred revenue schedules or equity records in a handback. They lose the WIP schedule, the estimated cost to complete on every open job, committed cost, retainage, and the package the bank and the surety ask for each year.
The harder thing to hand over is how each job was costed, who decides when percent complete changes, and why over and under billings are what they are. That knowledge lives in the monthly WIP process. If you do take the work in-house, run the overlap on the WIP schedule first, job by job, and have the outgoing team explain every difference. A comparison of trial balances alone won't surface it. A WIP schedule that works as a diagnostic is the thing to hand over cleanly.
The numbers we use on our own site are $110,000 to $150,000 in salary for a construction controller and $50,000 to $65,000 for a construction bookkeeper. Add 25 percent for payroll taxes and benefits and you get $137,500 to $187,500 for the controller and $62,500 to $81,250 for the bookkeeper. Together that is $200,000 to $268,750 a year, plus a one-time recruiting cost of about 20 percent of first-year salary.
Our outsourced construction accounting starts at $5,000 a month, which is $60,000 a year. Our construction controller services, for a contractor that keeps its bookkeeper, start at $4,000 a month, or $48,000 a year. We go through the same comparison in outsourced accounting for contractors.
Cost is not the whole question. If you have enough volume to keep a full-time controller busy and a team underneath them, hiring is the right answer, and our controller services page says so.
Most contractors who bring accounting back end up keeping some of it outside. The split that works follows the monthly cycle. Keep the work that sits close to your people, like entering bills and applying payments. Put WIP, job costing, and the month-end close with someone who does them for a living and works in your system. Payroll stays with your payroll provider and tax returns stay with your tax preparer. If you are weighing a bookkeeper against a controller for the work you keep, read bookkeepers vs. controllers in construction.
Write down what went wrong. If you have hired a controller, or your volume has outgrown the arrangement, bring it in. If the real problem is that you can't see job profit until three weeks after month end, look at the process before the staffing model, because both models can produce late WIP.
If you want to talk through which of these fits your company, book a call with Levvigo. You can also read how our construction controller services, outsourced construction accounting and WIP preparation services work and what they cost.