Contractors ask me some version of this question all the time. They have an accountant, or they're about to hire one, and they want to know whether that person knows construction or just knows accounting. Most of the answers you'll hear are about technical knowledge like job costing, retainage, percentage of completion, and the WIP schedule. Those things matter, and I've written about them in Does Your Controller Understand Construction Accounting? I don't think they're the biggest difference, though.
After more than 15 years in construction accounting, the first thing I look at is how the accountant gets information. A generic accountant works with what arrives in the office. A construction accountant knows that the most important information in the company is out on the jobs, and treats getting it into the office as a central part of the work.
I don't mean "generic" as an insult. A good generic accountant has the fundamentals. They understand debits and credits, they can prepare and read financial statements, and they keep an accurate record of what has already happened. Many of them can build a projection, and most are good at financial reporting. In a lot of businesses that is the whole job, and it's a hard job to do well.
It works because in most businesses the information the accountant needs shows up as documents. Invoices, bank statements, payroll reports, and sales records come to the office, and the accountant records them. In construction those documents only give you part of what you need. You can record every invoice correctly and still not know how a job is doing, because the answer depends on how much work is left and what it will cost to finish. That isn't on any invoice. The project manager and the superintendent know it, and accounting only knows it if they tell accounting.
One of the most valuable things a construction accountant does is build the processes that get timely, accurate, reliable information about jobs from the field into the office. That includes estimates to complete, change orders that have been agreed to but not yet signed, labor hours and quantities, materials that have been delivered but not invoiced, and what can be billed this month. Every one of those starts with someone in the field. None of it reaches accounting unless somebody has built a way for it to get there.
In some meaningful ways that makes a construction accountant's work less accounting-y than a generic accountant's. A lot of it is agreeing with the project managers on what they'll send and when, setting up a routine for it, and following up until the routine becomes a habit. It also means getting out of the office. A construction accountant walks the job sites, sees what's going on, and asks questions. You learn things standing on a job with the superintendent that a cost report won't tell you. When the accountant works remotely, a regular call with the project manager and the superintendent does the same job.
A process on paper isn't enough, because these processes run on relationships. A project manager who knows and trusts the accountant sends the updated estimate on time and calls when a job starts to go sideways. A project manager who thinks of accounting as the department that sends forms and asks for receipts does the minimum, and does it late. A construction accountant gets this and puts real time into those relationships. I wrote about what happens when the pipeline is missing in Many job-status questions are really documentation questions.
To build those pipelines the accountant needs credibility with the field, and a title doesn't provide it. Project managers and superintendents are busy, and most requests from accounting look like more paperwork to them. If all they ever get from the office is requests, they have little reason to make accounting a priority.
One of the best ways I know to earn that credibility is to give field operations information they can use. A project manager wants to know where the job stands against budget by cost code, what has been committed and not yet spent, which change orders haven't been billed, and how labor hours are tracking against the estimate. An accountant who brings that to the project manager, current and easy to read, has given them something that helps them run the job. Do that consistently and the project manager starts to see accounting as a source of help.
That goodwill is what lets the construction accountant do what they really need to do. When the same accountant asks for an updated estimate to complete by the fifth of the month, they get it. It's usually a better estimate too, because the project manager has been looking at good cost data all month. The information going out to the field and the information coming back depend on each other, and a construction accountant works on both. The monthly WIP is where you see whether it's working, which I covered in Your WIP schedule is a diagnostic, not just a report.
Start by asking where the numbers come from. If the estimated cost to complete on each job is the original budget minus costs to date, or nobody in accounting can tell you when the project managers last updated their estimates, you probably have a generic accountant. Ask how often they talk to your project managers and what they talk about. Ask when they were last on a job site.
Then ask your project managers what they get from accounting. If they describe a report they look at every week and use to run the job, you have a construction accountant. If they describe requests for cost codes and receipts, you have your answer there too.
None of this means a generic accountant can't become a construction accountant. Plenty have. The technical side can be learned, and I laid out where to start in How to Learn Construction Accounting. The habit of going to the field for information takes longer, and it's usually learned from someone who already works that way.
Levvigo trains its accountants in construction accounting and in working with project managers to get job information into the office. If you want that kind of help with your WIP schedule, learn about our WIP preparation services.